A Papal Conclave, Coming Soon: After Benedict XVI’s Resignation, What to Know about the Election of the New Pope

Come March, all eyes will be on St. Peter's Basilica for news of the new Pope!

Come March, all eyes will be on St. Peter’s Basilica for news of the new Pope!

Rome—and the world—has been rocked by the announcement that Pope Benedict XVI will resign on February 28, meaning that the Vatican will hold a papal conclave in March.

Pope Benedict XVI has shocked the world by announcing his decision to resign at the end of February.

Pope Benedict XVI has shocked the world by announcing his decision to resign at the end of February.

The Pope will be the first since 1415 to abdicate his seat, seemingly for health reasons. That’s big news not only for Catholics, but for anyone planning to come to Rome in March, when the election for the new pope will occur.

But what exactly is a conclave, who can vote, and who can be elected? The answers might surprise you!

What is a conclave, exactly?

In Vatican-speak, “conclave” describes two different things: The closed room that cardinals stay in when they’re electing a new pope, and the assembly of the cardinals itself. The word comes from cum clave (Latin for “with a key”), describing how the cardinals were locked up while they made the decision.

Have conclaves always been the way to elect a new pope?

No. Before the 13th century, papal selection could drag on for months or even years, leaving a dangerous power vacuum between popes. After Clement IV died in 1268, the six cardinals nominated to pick his successor debated for almost three years!

Enter the decision of the Second Council of Lyons in 1274, which set up the conclave rules that are still, more or less, followed today. To keep the process from dragging on forever, they said that 10 days after the Pope’s death, cardinals should meet in the palace of the city where he died. They had to assemble in one room—the conclave—and they weren’t allowed to leave: They had to sleep next to each other and take all their meals there. They weren’t allowed to send out any messages, and their discussions were held strictly in private.

If that wasn’t enough to hurry up the decision? Here’s where things got harsh: If the cardinals didn’t agree on a new pope within three days, their food was rationed. If they still hadn’t agreed, five days later, their food was lessened even more.

Guess what? It worked. The first conclave lasted a day. The one after that, a week.

Are conclaves always held in the Sistine Chapel?

Today, papal conclaves are held here in the Sistine Chapel.

Today, papal conclaves are held here in the Sistine Chapel.

They are now. But the Sistine Chapel wasn’t built until the end of the 15th century, so obviously, they weren’t always held here! (The first was held here in 1492, and all conclaves since 1878 have been held in the Sistine Chapel).

While voting occurs in the Sistine Chapel, though, the cardinals don’t live and sleep there during the conclave. Up until 1996, cardinals slept in simple rooms and rented cots in the Vatican palaces, sharing bathrooms with one another. It was still a step up from the stricter days of the 13th century, but in 1996, Pope John Paul II—who had been through two conclaves himself, and seen how difficult they were for older, ailing cardinals—had the Domus Sanctae Marthae erected. It offers furnished, private rooms from single rooms to more-deluxe suites (assigned at random, regardless of the cardinal’s rank); dining facilities are there, as well.

While that’s cushier than it was in the past, the cardinals do still, of course, have to give up their connection to the outside world: No radios, television, or telephones are connected during the conclave.

Who’s eligible to be pope?

More people than you might think! Contrary to popular belief, according to Vatican law, you don’t have to be a cardinal to be chosen. (Of course, the last time that happened was 1378, with Urban VI. But still).

Current Dean of the College of Cardinals, Cardinal Sodano

More surprisingly still, you don’t even have to have a Church career. Even a layman can be elected pope. (The last time that happened: Celestine V, 1294). Even a married man could be elected!

Granted, it’s hardly likely that we’ll see any of these come to pass in 2013. But it was hardly likely Benedict XVI would become the first pope in 600 years to resign, either. So who knows!

The one thing we can be sure of, given current Vatican law: The pope can’t be a heretic, or female.

Who’s allowed to vote?

Any cardinal under 80 years of age. There are about 200 cardinals, and currently, 118 are eligible to vote.

How does voting work?

It’s usually—but not necessarily—by secret ballot. Called scrutinium, the secret ballot requires a two-thirds majority for the election to be called. But it’s not completely secret, in that every cardinal’s vote can be distinguished by a Scripture text written on one of its folds. The reason? If the vote is close, the ballot of the pope-elect can be singled out and checked to make sure he didn’t vote for himself.

Two votes are taken each day, one in the morning, one in the evening. And here comes the fun part: When the two-thirds majority isn’t obtained, the ballots are put into a stove in the Sistine Chapel… and black smoke pipes out the chimney, visible to everyone on St. Peter’s Square. When the Pope is chosen? White smoke!

What happens to the new pope when he’s elected?

The first thing he does is accept the election (hopefully, anyway!), and announce the name that he’s chosen for himself. (This is a tradition dating back to the 11th century). He’s conducted to another room, where he dons the garments of the Pope, and the cardinals line up to pay him homage. The Fisherman’s Ring is put on his finger, and then he goes to meet the public: He makes his first proclamation as Pope from St. Peter’s Basilica. That’s the first moment the world discovers who the new pope is!

How long does this all take?

There’s no telling, but the last few conclaves have been relatively swift. Pope John Paul II  was elected after two days, while Pope Benedict XVI was elected after just one. So if you want your chance to see the white smoke puff out of the Sistine Chapel, get to St. Peter’s Square on the first day—and be prepared to wait out the day!

, , , , ,

7 Responses to A Papal Conclave, Coming Soon: After Benedict XVI’s Resignation, What to Know about the Election of the New Pope

  1. betty green February 11, 2013 at 9:10 pm #

    i do think that the pope is doing the wright thing he is not well you can see that he has gone down hill you all have to think about all that he has done for are country it is sad to see him go but he does have to rest i my self was brought up with my brother in the catholic regligon we had to go to church every moreing & befour we left school for that day god bless him we all love you betty geen

  2. RBartlett February 15, 2013 at 9:06 pm #

    Does anyone know if the Sistine Chapel and St. Peter’s Basilica will be closed for the entire month of March 2013? I will be in Rome in March and have tickets to tour them!

  3. Leo Higgins March 1, 2013 at 2:17 am #

    What if the newly elected pope is not at the conclave? How do they send for him to see if he accepts? How do they get him to the conclave and into his vestments without tipping off people who he is? Universi Dominici Gregis mentions that such a case is covered by norms in the Ordo Rituum Conclavis, but this second document is not quoted in UDG and it doesn’t seem to be available via websearches. Does anybody know what is said about this in ORC?

    • walksofitaly March 4, 2013 at 5:37 pm #

      Hi Leo,
      The specificities of the laws aside, tradition tells us it’s pretty unlikely that the elected pope wouldn’t be a cardinal, and all cardinals are supposed to be at the conclave—so that hasn’t been a problem yet, that we know of. Then again, this is a year of firsts… so who knows! Stay tuned!


  1. The Sistine Chapel, Currently Closed for the 2013 Papal Conclave - March 7, 2013

    [...] the year was 1415. So this is an especially historic event! (Check out our earlier post for more on exactly what a papal conclave really is and how it [...]

  2. Crash course on the Papal Conclave: 8 Handy Resources — Browsing Rome - March 11, 2013

    [...] 3. A Papal Conclave, Coming Soon: After Benedict XVI’s Resignation, What to Know about the Election o… - Walks of Italy [...]

  3. Wrap-up of the 2013 Papal Conclave: What to Know about the New Pope Francis I, When the Sistine Chapel Reopens, and More - March 14, 2013

    [...] in the Sistine Chapel and elect a new pope. (Here’s everything you ever wanted to know about a papal conclave and how it works!).  The conclave took place this week. After only a day and a half, the cardinals elected Jorge [...]

Leave a Reply